The undersigned, prosecutors within the Public Ministry, observing the principle of the separation of powers in the state and the general requirement to abstain from having any particular political stance, taking note of the public discussions on the duties and activity of the prosecutors as well as the issues inserted in the minutes of the Romanian Constitutional Court’s decision dated May 30, 2018,
In view of the Bangalore Principles that allow magistrates to freely express their opinions when their independence is affected or when there is a risk of prejudicing the separation and balance of powers in the state,
Taking into account the standards imposed by the United Nations Principles on the role of the Prosecutor, adopted in Havana in 1990, the Council of Europe Recommendation (2000) 19 on the role of the prosecutor in the criminal justice system, Professional Accountability Standards and the Declaration on the Obligations and Rights of Public Prosecutors adopted by the International Association of Prosecutors on 23 April 1999, the Venice Commission’s Report on European Standards for the Independence of the Judiciary (CDL_AD (2010) 040) adopted on 17-18 December 2010, Opinion no. 9 (2014) of the Consultative Council of European Prosecutors (Rome Charter)
Considering that the Romanian State understands to fulfil its international obligations regarding the independence of the judiciary and the protection of the rule of law and to observe the rules imposed by the European Union and the Council of Europe as well as by the other international organizations of which Romania is part of,
we understand to commit at individual level to the declaration of principles below:
Our activity will always take place in accordance with the constitutional role provided by art. 131 par. (1) of the Romanian Constitution, defending the general interests of society, the rule of law as well as the rights and freedoms of citizens. We respect the competences of the Minister of Justice regarding the state’s criminal policy as well as the specific attributions in certain areas, but these competences do not validate in any way the involvement of the political factor in the ways of investigating and solving criminal cases. The Minister of Justice has no and will not have any involvement or role in our professional activity or in any criminal or civil case that we have for resolution or where we participate as representatives of the Public Ministry.
The only institution that manages the career of the prosecutor and the only guarantor of the independence of prosecutors is the Superior Council of Magistracy and according to art. 1 par. (2) of Law 304/2004the Minister of Justice has and can have no role or involvement in the individual career of the prosecutor, and this principle cannot be modified by inserting a specific phrase in the Constitutional Court’s decision, an institution which has no competence to legislate positively. We draw attention to the fact that the professional evaluation of prosecutors and the way in which they are to take office must be based on a meritocratic system, on clear and transparent conditions and rules and a lack of arbitrariness.
We urge all competent institutions and all decision-makers to respect the principles of the functioning of the European Union, to facilitate the fulfilment of Romania’s international obligations and take into account that respect for the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary is an important point in the field of international cooperation and the capacity of Romania to be a partner of dialogue in relation to the other Member States, both with regards to cooperation in criminal matters and cooperation in civil matters.
In support of this statement of principle we note that guaranteeing the independence of the judiciary was one of the conditions required for membership of the European Union, a context in which the changes to the package of laws on the judiciary were adopted, specifically guaranteeing the independence and stability of the prosecutor, by amending the provisions of art. 3 par. (1) of Law 303/2004 („The prosecutors appointed by the President of Romania enjoy stability and are independent, according to the law”). Romania’s obligation regarding the rule of law and guaranteeing the independence of the judiciary continued after the moment of accession, being one of the criteria considered in the CVM evaluations, so we cannot consider that an approach that diminishes the statute of the prosecutor magistrate could be anything other than an infringement of the commitments assumed as a Member State.
We also draw attention to the fact that the Havana Rules on the role of the Prosecutor, adopted by the United Nations in 1990, require States to ensure that prosecutors can exercise their functions without being exposed to intimidation, harassment and interference.
As a member of the Council of Europe, the Romanian state must consider and respect international notices, and in this respect the Charter of Rome lays down as European standards and principles regarding the activity of prosecutors the following: „Independence and autonomy of the Public Ministry is a indispensable corollary to the independence of the judiciary. Prosecutors should be autonomous in decision-making and should carry out their tasks outside any external interference and pressure, according to the principles of separation of powers and responsibility „
The independence of the prosecutor and the prosecutor’s impartiality are two essential elements in international standards, being regarded as key human rights issues, both from an institutional as well as an individual point of view. The independence and impartiality of the prosecutor magistrate are not his personal benefits but the guarantees necessary for the fulfilment of the function of the Public Ministry in the structure of a law-based state or the authority responsible for the enforcement of the criminal law on behalf of and for the benefit of society and the public interest, taking into account both the rights of the individual and the necessary effectiveness of the criminal justice system. (Council of Europe Recommendation (2000) 19, paragraph 1)
Both the Council of Europe Recommendation and the Venice Commission Report underline the need to ensure transparent and fair procedures with no political influence in terms of admission to the profession, promotion system and prosecutor’s work. Thus, the procedures guaranteeing a correct selection of prosecutors and those protecting the prosecutor from an arbitrary removal are important issues in guaranteeing the independence of the prosecutor. There is no benefit in creating a system in which the prosecutor is only apparently independent if the practical actions tend to involve the political factor in the judicial activity.
In this respect, the Venice Commission underlined that the prosecutor’s independence is a mechanism to prevent the interference of the political or any other factor in the criminal prosecution activity and states must provide the necessary framework for the prosecutor’s decisions to be taken impartially and just as the judge is required to act fairly and impartially without being subjected to the pressure of other external factors.
The Venice Commission report on judicial independence emphasizes that „A clear distinction needs to be made between the interest of persons holding power in the State and the general interest. The assumption that the two aspects overlap is present in many European countries. Ideally, the exercise of functions of general interest must not be combined or confused with the functions of the executive power at a particular moment in time, the interests of other institutions, or even the interests of any political party.” Considering the legal obligations of the Public Ministry, both at constitutional level and at the level of other legal instruments, we underline that as prosecutors our role is to defend the public interest, understood as the interest of the citizens in a democratic state and we will exercise this role independently and impartially, without regard to temporary circumstance.
List of signatures:
- Bradea Dumitru Vlad – Parchetul de pe lângă Judecătoria Oradea
- Corina Dinică – PT Argeș
- Lăncrănjan Alexandra Carmen – DNA Structura Centrală
- Margina Cătălin – PT Bacău
- Tagheiv Ramona – PT Bacău
- Finică Sorina – PT Bacău
- Atomei Adriana – PT Bacău
- Trif Marian Mihai – PJ Turda
- Iulia Crișan – DNA Structura Centrală
- Simona Anghel – PJ Oltenita
- Mihaela Beldie – DNA Structura Centrală
- Răzvan Alexandru Băra – PJ Brașov
- Cristina Scarlat DNA
- Aurelian Ioan Ardelean – DNA
- Radu Florin Ionescu – DNA
- Cosmin Iordache – DNA
- Adriana Pau – PJ Sector 2
- Codreanu Alexandru – PT Brașov
- Raluca Alexandra Munteanu – PJ Sector 2
- Berende Ruxandra Maria PJ Satu Mare
- Roxana Andreea Codreanu PJ IAsi
- Laurentiu Grecu – PT Gorj
- Lia Sorin Marian – PJ Corabia
- Carmen VAmesu – DNA
- Daniela Lupu – DNA
- Alexandru Liviu Colceriu – PJ Intorsura Buzaului
- Cosmina Mihaela Vieriu – PJ Zarnesti
- Calin Radu Bogdan – PJ Sector 1
- Coralia Lapadat – PJ Arad
- Dordea Marcian Silviu – PJ Blaj
- Luminita Boca – DNA ST Cluj
- Bogdan Pîrlog – PT Militar Bucuresti
- Andra Dutescu – PJ Sector 2
- Stroescu Bobby Sorin – PJ Timisoara
- Curici Seia Iasmina- PJ Deta
- Ghita Alina Andreea – PJ Turda
- Laura Dobrea – PT Brăila
- Ciutac Mircea – PT Brăila
- Dedulescu Liviu Ionuț – PT Brăila
- Velea Gheorghe – PJ Brăila
- Marinescu Mihaela – PJ Însurăței
- Pungă Tudorel – PJ Însurăței
- Baraș Iulian – PJ Bolintin Vale
- Barbu Camelia Liliana – PJ Bolintin Vale
- Tomescu Alexandra Sorina – PJ Bolintin Vale
- Cotovelea Ionel – PJ Câmpulung
- Gheorghe Daniel – PJ Câmpulung
- Lobodan Remus – PJ Câmpulung
- Visovan Cristina Ingrid – PJ Sighetu Marmatiei
- Adrian Meda Titu- DNA ST Cluj
- Irimia Anca Emilia – PJ Sibiu
- Cristina Frîncu – PJS 2
- Ioana Vernea PJS2
- Sohorca Florin PJ Alba Iulia
- Rotundu Simon PJ Iasi
- Cîrciumaru Oprică Florin PJS 2
- Doina Stanta – PCA Craiova
- Bunduc Marian Catalin – DIICOT Structura Centrală
- Arpinte Nicoleta – PJ Dorohoi
- Stanciu Gabriela – DNA ST Constanta
- Valentin Toduta – PJ oradea
- Bursuc Andreea Claudia – DIICOT
- Anca Iovan DIICOT Serviciul Teritorial Brasov
- Lohan Iulia Maria – PJ Sighetul Marmatiei
- Cristina Radu – PT Bucuresti
- Sendroni Mircea – PJ Cluj Napoca
- Marian Clement Virgil – PJ Baia Mare
- Asmarandei Andrei Iulian – PT Ilfov
- Carnariu Bianca Dana – PJ Baia Mare
- Gabriel Tatar – PJ Cluj Napoca
- Tabirta Lorin PJ Timisoara
- Carnariu Mihai Madalin – PJ Baia Mare
- Buzoianu Mihaela Alexandra – PJ Calarasi
- Valentin Uritescu – PJ Negresti Oas
- Cosmin Ungureanu PT Valcea
- Vlad Alexandru Bentan – PJ oradea
- Marin Ana Maria PT Brasov
- Ioana Gutu PT Valcea
- Daniel Giorgian PJ galati
- Cristina Voicu DNA Structura Centrala
- Morosan Andrada Sabina PJ Timisoara
- Pop Blaga Marius PJ Oradea
- Alba Radu Ioan PJ Oradea
- Popescu Adriana Mihaela PT Valcea
- Radu Adrian PJ Brasov
- Ostafie Andrei PJ Botosani
- Laura Zaharia DIICOT Iasi
- Ciobanu Ionica Daniel PJ Caracal
- Mihaela Mihai Popa – DNA ST Suceava
- Marin Călusaru – DNA ST Craiova
- Ramona Jardieanu – DNA Structura Centrala
- Damaschin Ioana Teodora – PJ Cluj Napoca
- Bocai Adina PCA Iasi
- Mihai Negulescu DIICOT ST Brasov
- Dobre Aurelia Madalina PJ Arad
- Panainte Iulian PJ Harlau
- Sorin Daniel Beteringhe PT Bihor
- Paunica Ionut PJ Calarasi
- Gus Octavia Raluca PT Alba
- Pacuraru Mihaela PJ Calarasi
- Marinescu Lucian PT Valcea
- Burga Florin PJ Sf Gheorghe
- Matei Leontin PJS 4
- Pitrop Cristina Beatrice PJ Constanta
- Ioan Bene PJ TG Bujor
- Sandu Claudiu Costantin PT Brasov
- Mihail Andreca PJ Timisoara
- Mihai Valentin DIICOT Structura Centrală
- Dobre Mihai Alexandru PJ Arad
- Onea Dalidis Nicoleta Irina PCA Craiova
- Iulian Nica – PT Brasov
- Anghel Alexandru Bogdan PJ Segarcea
- Serban Viorel Florin PJS 2
- Iulia Bilciu DNA Structura Centrala
- Daniel Ciumărnean DNA ST Cluj
- Paul Dumitriu DNA Structura Centrală
- Danusia Boicean DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Alina RAsovan DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Daniel Dumitru DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Călin Tatu DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Florin Nanu DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Anca Gabriela Mărincean DNA ST Cluj
- Horatius Baias DNA Structura Centrală
- Stancele Diana DNA Structura Centrala
- Constantin Irina DNA Structura Centrala
- Daniel Apetroaei – DNA St Bacău
- Anemaria Ruxandra Cireap – DNA
- Oana Peltechi – PCA Bucuresti
- Roca Carmil DNA ST Bacău
- Robert Adrian Nicolicescu DNA
- Daniela Dumitrache – DNA
- Violeta Sechely – DNA Structura Centrală
- Florin Bogdan Munteanu DNA ST Iasi
- Iordache Laura Nicoleta PJS 1
- Lucanu Iuliana DIICOT
- Tudor Antoniu Vasiu – PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Adi Lucian Răduică PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Pena Laura Nadia PCA Bacau
- Gheorghe Mihai Andrei PJ Pitesti
- Puscas Madalina PJ Alba Iulia
- Zlate Nadia DNA ST Constanta
- David Maricel – PT Ilfov
- Povăliceanu Cristina – PT Arad
- Roman Nelu – PJ Baia Mare
- Bradin Aurora PJ Arad
- Monica Munteanu DNA ST Brasov
- Vestemeanu Raluca DIICOT ST Brasov
- Cornel David Deca DNA ST Brasov
- Andreea Ghenu DNA ST Brasov
- Dundev Alma Maria PJ Sighisoara
- Batrinu Iuliana PJ Focsani
- Brindea Dan Eugen PT Salaj
- Cepoi Marian PJ Nasaud
- Dunca Ioan PJ Baia Mare
- Varga Zoltan PJ Baia Mare
- Scutea Gabriela PCA Brasov
- Ghita Bogdan – DNA
- Bontea Cristina Augustina PJ Petrosani
- Baldea Diana PT IAsi
- Satmarici Iulia Diana PJ Medgidia
- Mircea Alexandra Nora PJ Turda
- Radu Florea PJ Turda
- Ghidiu Liliana Maria PT Alba
- Panciuc Anca Clara – PJ Radauti
- Remus Budai – DNA Structura Centrala
- Ion Izabela Ana Maria PJ Sector 3
- Stefanita Gogea DIICOT
- Cristina Chiriac DNA
- Cosarca Nicolae PJ Targu Mures
- Diremia Vlad PJ Rosiori De vede
- Buda Dorel PJ Baia Mare
- Alice Jemboiu PCA Craiova
- Maria Piturcă PCA Craiova
- Marius Sulu PT Brasov
- Grigore alina Gabriela PJ Targoviste
- Mihai Irina PJ Targoviste
- Bosânciuc Paul Cosmin PJ Targoviste
- Stoica Florin PJ Targoviste
- Aldea Adrian PT Brasov
- Cerasela Ungureanu PT Brasov
- Câțu Lilisor PJ Brasov
- Câțu Codruța Romana Maria PJ Brasov
- Nita Manole Simona Daniela PJ Ploiesti
- Dragu Corina PT Brasov
- Fânariu Stefan PJ Saveni
- Nistor Gigi PJ Filiasi
- Cristina Mocioi PJ Babadag
- Ursa Paul Ionel PJ Zarnesti
- Comanescu Cătălin PJ Horezu
- Ana Muresan PJS 2 delegat PTB
- Nită Manole Simona Daniela PJ Ploiesti
- Corina Avornicitei PJ Sector 1
- Raluca Anghel Gheorghe DNA Structura Centrală
- Alin Eduard Poterasu DNA Structura Centrala
- Veronica Luminita Leonte DNA ST Suceava
- Maria Luiza Capatana DNA Structura Centrală
- Mosteanu Marian Eugen DNA ST Craiova
- Ionuț Vasile DNA ST Cluj
- Alexandru Diana DNA ST Galați
- Popescu Gabriela DNA ST Galați
- Ivascu Dorina DNA ST Galați
- Mihaela Leu DNA ST Galați
- Năvădaru Mădălin DNA ST Galați
- Lucian Rău DNA ST Galați
- Diana Alexandru DNA ST Galați
- Andreea Oana Nica DNA
- Eugen Stănculescu DNA ST Craiova
- Tiberiu Nicolae Onea – DNA ST Tîrgu Mureș
- Drăgulescu Marian DNA Structura Centrală
- Gabriela Iancu DNA ST Cluj
- Ioana Borjog PJ Sector 1
- Ionela Bălan DNA Structura Centrală
- Ana Maria Nedelcu DNA Structura Centrală
- Cornelia Hrincescu DNA ST Bacău
- Antonia Diaconu – PJ Topoloveni
- Nanu Vladimir PT Argeș
- Moraru Alina – DNA ST Iasi
- Dorcu Lavinia PJ Corabia
- Irina Paraschiv PJ Brezoi
- Stefan Ispasoiu DNA ST Brasov
- Gheorghiu Anca Loredana PJ Brasov
- Corina Mois PJ Satu Mare
- Miu Madalina PT Calarasi
- Marinel Nicolae PT Olt
- Couti Roxana PT Maramures
- Maris Constantina PT Maramures
- Apetri Oana PT Brasov
- Couti Crinel PT Maramures
- Simion Oana PJ Brasov
- Rosca Sergiu PJ Satu Mare
- Claudiu Statache PJ Constanta
- Stasiuc Mădălina PJ Targu Mures
- Alexandra Dordea DNA Structura Centrală
- Branzei Alexandru PJ Baia Mare
- Baran Florin PJ Sector 4
- Rus Lavinia PJ Faget
- Mircea Iuliana PCA Constanta
- Ioan Sandru PICCJ
- Dan Obreja PJ TG Mures
- Maria Rimniceanu DIICOT ST BRASOV
- Azamfirei Daniela Elena PJ Galati
- Cristina Maria Luca PT Neamț
- Pelmuș Ciprian PJ Timisoara
- Arvinte Ramona PJS3
- Olteanu Dragoș PJ Timisoara
- Catalin Moraru PJ Brasov
- Vlad Crăciun PJ Sighisoara
- Pelinel Monica Cristina PT Valcea
- Ghinea Alexandru Cosmin PJ Fetesti
- Sorin Constantinescu DNA ST Constanta
- Apostol Mihaela PT Iasi
- Cojoaca Traian PJ Rosiori de Vede
- Munge Mircea Florin PJ Oradea
- Alina Hubert PJ Pitesti
- Topliceanu Constantin PJ Pitesti
- Doncea Andrei PT Ilfov
- Ungureanu Alin PJ Deta
- Ceaușu Alexandru Octavian PJ Timisoara
- Blanaru Larisa Andreea PJ Brasov
- Mocanu Simona Elena PJ Brasov
- Aurelian Manzu PT Arad
- Alina Ghinescu DIICOT ST CV
- Bochis Angela PJ Cornetu
- Dumitrache Nicusor Adrian PJS 4
- Olca Diana Andreea PJ Satu Mare
- Sovarschi Laura PJ Alesd
- Lazar Ancuta PJ Satu Mare
- Meszaros Ioana Adina PJ Satu mare
- Betea Florin Dorin PJ Satu Mare
- Mic Ioana PT satu Mare
- Bocai Tudor Florin PT Hunedoara
- Cuciureanu Iulia Maria PJ Brasov
- Iordache Valeriu PJ Ploiesti
- Airinei Lucia PT Harghita
- Iosifescu Iulian Răzvan PT Harghita
- Colceriu Sorin Mihai PT Harghita
- Gîlcescu Dan PT Harghita
- Grigore Cristian PT Harghita
- Fabian Orsolya Kinga PT Harghita
- Tokos Lehel PT Harghita
- Deac Corvin Doru PJ Miercurea Ciuc
- German Cristina PJ Miercurea Ciuc
- Chiriac Dragos PJ Miercurea Ciuc
- Ivănescu Georgică PJ Odorheiu Secuiesc
- Suto Agota Kinga PJ Odorheiu Secuiesc
- Papuc Mădălina Diana PJ Odorheiu Secuiesc
- Vasile Tudor Iulian PJ Fetesti
- Buculea Raluca PJ Timisoara
- Popa Alina Diana PJ Iasi
- Marcu Ionut DIICOT
- Cristina Gavriliuc DNA ST Bacau
- Giluela Deaconu DNA
- Ioan Ulici DNA
- Cerasela Răileanu DNA
- Angelica Paraschivescu DNA ST Pitesti
- Dana Păun PJS1
- Florina Nicoleta Sirbu PJS1
- Maria Mihut PJS 2
- Corina Petrescu PJS 1
- Florea Alexandru DIICOT
- Preda Andrei Bogdan DIICOT
- Dan Cristian Ene DIICOT
- Cristian Florea DIICOT
- Ionela Florea DIICOT
- Apostol Giorgiana Violeta PJ Constanta
- Nita Cosmin PJ Ploiesti
- Ciotu Roxana PJ Suceava
- Pirvu Ana Maria PJ Slobozia
- Totora Vlad Cosmin PJ Segarcea
- Cioban Vasile Călin PJ Turda
- Valentin Enache PJ Brezoi
- Simona Stefania Constantinescu DNA
- Iuliana Mihoc PJ Ploiesti
- Neculaica Elena PT Constanta
- Oprea Veronica Nicoleta PJ Buzău delegat DNA ST Ploiesti
- Salaru Ilie Andrei PJS1
- Colț Mihail PJ Brăila
- Ionela Tinca PJ Brașov
- Buse Ionel PJ Valcea
- Tosu Zoltan Eugen PJ Dragasani
- Florentina Mirica DNA Structura Centrală
- Streza Laurentiu PJ Valcea
- Sava Alexandra Teona PJ Harlau
- Serban irina PJ Slatina
- Stefan Gheorghe Daniel PT Bacau
- Bogdan Stoica PJ Dragasani
- Marius Valcu DNA Structura Centrală
- Lazar Anca PCA Cluj
- Popescu Cristian Ovidiu PJ Caracal
- Gheorghe Popovici DNA Structura Centrală
- Ungureanu Irina PJ Sighisoara
- Ursu Oana Alina PJ Giurgiu
- Rosiu Mihaela PJS 5
- Zavera Irina PJ Timisoara
- Sas Anca Raluca PJ Turda
- Lungu Ramona PT Arad
- Lazăr Aida PJ Timisoara
- Rusu Larisa PJ Botosani
- Raluca Nor Bosnea PJ Timisoara
- Cîmpean Ioana Elena PJS 2
- Povaliceanu Claudia PJ Timisoara
- Bradean Raluca Cristina PJ Caransebes
- Ailioaei Ramona PJ Pascani
- Stoenescu Roxana PJS 4
- Cătălin Galcea PJS4
- Hogas Marius PJ Râmnicu Vâlcea
- Stroe Cristina PJ Dragasani
- Mociran Adela PT Maramures
- Tătar Emanuela Anca PJ Brăila
- Sfîca Aglaia Irina PJ Iasi
- Fraiu Flaviu PJ Timișoara
- Galatan Anișoara Voichita PJS 6
- Simon Dragos PJ Cluj Napoca
- Todea LAurentiu Mirel PJ Timisoara
- Derius Laura DNA Structura Centrala
- Pop Ciprian Dumitru PJ Ludus
- Murariu Ovidiu Daniel PJ Ludus
- Ciuche Lucian DIICOT
- Dinică Mihai PJ Făurei
- Topală Teodor Bogdan DIICOT
- Meszar Alexandru Voicu PJ Carei
- Pricop Elena Mădălina PJ Iași
- Țapliuc Cristina PJ Iasi
- Corogeanu Cristian Andrei PJ Timisoara
- Albulescu Camelia PJ Cornetu
- Ioșca Alina PJ Cornetu
- Serban Daniel Mihai PJ Brașov
- Gordan Sorin PT Brăila
- Chivu Claudia Irina PJ Timisoara
- Olariu Nicusor PJ Caransebes
- Mustață Liviu PT Caraș Severin
- Hosu Andrei PT Caraș Severin
- Patras Alexandra Maria PJ Iași
- Pelmus Atena PT Timiș
- Mihoc Emanuel PJ Sighișoara
- Galatanu Maria PJ Baia Mare
- Simion Daniel PJ Focsani
- Stanciu Gabriela Daniela PJ Brăila
- Corogeanu Cristian Andrei PJ Timișoara
- Negrău Andrei Sergiu PJ Salonta
- Georgescu Ruxandra Diana PJ Suceava
- Călinescu Diana PJ Suceava
- Cătălin Chiochiu PJ Suceava
- Doina Popa PJ Pitești
- Nicolae Argeșanu PJ Pitești
- Simona Florescu PJ Pitești
- Cătălin Barbuceanu PCA Pitești
- Oprea Mihai Tatiana DIICOT
- Olaru Mihaiela DIICOT
- Cristian Ichim DIICOT ST Brasov
- Zaharia Adrian Constantin PJ Suceava
- Cristina Garda PJ Galați
- Scorta Robert PJ Petrosani
- Popescu Cristian PJ Caracal
- Bonda Alexandru Vasile PJ Timisoara
- Andrei Florin Ciprian DIICOT Bacău
- Ciocan Gheorghe PJ Severin
- Marin Călușaru DNA ST Craiova
- Varga Sanda Daria PCA Cluj
- Diana Nicoleta Gitan PT Timiș
- Constantin Conortos DNA ST Constanta
- Diac Ana Maria PJS1
- Crăciun Achim Ovidiu PJ Brăila
- Luminița Popa DNA
- Emanuel Hau PJ Timișoara
- Daniela Chiazna PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Florina Băilescu PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Bărbulescu Florin Alexandru PJ Călărași
- Natavala Iuliu DNA
- Vlad Grigorescu DNA
- Tiba Morar Anca PJ Oradea
- Ion Teodor Valentin PJ Pitești
- Adrian Mihai PJ Pitești
- Cosmin Cristescu PJ Pitești
- Puiulescu Constantin Cosmin PT Argeș
- Ioan Paul Chiș DNA Structura Centrală
- Paul Leontică DIICOT ST Suceava
- Florentin Riza PT Dolj
- Tamara Manea PICCJ
- Adrian Ghirdoveanu DIICOT BT Dambovita
- Resmeriță Clement Mihai – DNA Structura Centrală
- Conortos Camelia Maria PT Constanta
- Constantinescu Mihai Marius DIICOT
- Ardelean Cristian DNA ST Oradea
- Chiazna Magdalena Daniela PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Moacă Mihaela Adriana PJ Buftea
- Ionuț Călina DIICOT
- Ionascu Cristina PJ Bacău
- Ionascu Cătălin PJ Bacău
- Benchea Vlad PJ Sibiu
- Mandache Ionut PJ Iași
- Fleckhammer Robert DIICOT
- Petrescu Erită Cosmin PJ Tg Jiu
- Onofrei Nichiforel Marius PT Botoșani
- Cristea Virgil – PJ Alba Iulia
- Cristea Denisa PJ Constanta
- Șimon Oana PJ Cluj Napoca
- Horșia Alexandru PJ Cluj Napoca
- Panțiru Florin PJ Cluj Napoca
- Spumă Oana Amalia PJ Cluj Napoca
- Mărginean Peczi Anamaria PJ Cluj Napoca
- Fadei Pavel PJ Cluj Napoca
- Nicoară Andra Laura PJ Cluj Napoca
- Ududec Ionel PJ Cluj Napoca
- Pantea Marius Călin PJ Cluj Napoca
- Tofan Florinela PJ Cluj Napoca
- Horge Diana Maria PJ Cluj Napoca
- Gheorghe Dragoș Ion PJ Cluj Napoca
- Mihai Laura Adina PJ Cluj Napoca
- Amuscăliței Alin PJ Cluj Napoca
- Mane Loredana Lăcrămioara PJ Cluj Napoca
- Birtoc Mihai Dorin PJ Cluj Napoca
- Delea Sarca Georgiana PJ Cluj Napoca
- Toader Aurelia Mirel PJ Cluj Napoca
- Ududec Anca Teodora PJ Cluj Napoca
- Kozma Bartok Szende Zenko PJ Cluj Napoca
- Borteș Mihai PJ Cluj Napoca
- Damaschin Ioana Teodora PJ Cluj Napoca
- Andreica Lucia Maria PJ Cluj Napoca
- Sfâriac Mihaela PT Cluj
- Renyi Erika PT Cluj
- Rășcanu Cristina PT Cluj
- Mihai Mesaros PJS 2
- Dinu Adrian Mihai PJ Constanta
- Laurentiu Iordan PJ Sibiu
- Cazacu Dan Constantin PJ Bacău
- Felicia Irina Popovici DNA
- Felicia Vlad DNA ST Brasov
- Adina Bidică PT Valcea
- Alexandra Maria Zernoveanu PJ Sfantu Gheorghe
- Cășuneanu Florin Daniel – PCA Iași
- Cojocar Rusanda PJ Brasov
- Gherghina Alina Nicoleta PJS 6
- Paduraru Raluca Mihaela PJS4
- Dinu Cristian Sorin DIICOT BT Sibiu
- Enache Simona DIICOT BT Sibiu
- Sava Gheorghe Petru DIICOT BT Sibiu
- Bidihon Flavius PJ Suceava
- Meszaros Tiberiu PJ Babadag
- Miroiu Floriana PJS 4
- Laura Gradina PT Tulcea
- Cristina Grosaru PJS 3
- Stefaniu Simona PT Covasna
- Stefaniu Bogdan PT Covasna
- Alina Neculaes PCA Bacău
- Andrei Jurca PJ Timisoara
- Sorin Pasăre PCA Craiova
- Pătulea Ioana – PJS 3
- Rosu Cristina PJ Giurgiu
- Mihaela Grigore PCA Bacau
- Andrei Dragan PJ Buftea
- Andrei Cristi PJ Răcari
- Carasel Stefana PJS 1
- Petrusca Gabriela Amalia PJ Buftea
- Ghilan Irina Brîndușa PJ Moinești
- Sandu Anca – PJ Piatra Neamț
- Ciopi Ani – PJ Baia Mare
- Matei Andreea Isabella PJ Buhusi
- Sarghi Dorina PJ Roman
- Maciuc Sorin PJS 6
Mulțumim colegilor judecători care susțin acest demers: Florin Zeres – Judecatoria Sibiu, Florina Carmen Ionescu – Tribunalul Neamt, Doina Zavalasi- CA Craiova, Mihaela Ion – Judecătoria Buzău, Iulian Dîrzeanu – Tribunalul București, Sorina Marinaș -CA Craiova, Florin Vilceanu – Tribunal Bucuresti, Ioana Liliana Molina Ramirez – Tribunalul Cluj, Anca Codreanu – Tribunalul Brașov, Liviu Cristian Cirneciu – Judecătoria Zărnesti, Cirneciu Felicia Tincuta – JS 2, Anca Demian – Judecatoria Hateg, Padeanu Catalina Petruta – Judecatoria Slatina, Sandu Maria Irina – Judecatoria Brasov, Madalina Birlog – Tribunalul Bucuresti, Cobiscan Alexandru – JS 1, Ioan Fundatureanu – CA Pitesti, Crina Capota – Judecatoria Dej, Balasanu Alexandru – Judecatoria Botosani, Popescu Adrian – Tribunalul Cluj, Popescu Luminita Teodora Judecatoria Mangalia, Neagos Sorina – CA Alba Iulia, Mandache Claudia – Judecătoria Iași, Dorin Parascheva – Judecatoria Constanta, Alina Stamate Tamasan – Tribunalul Maramures, Ambrozie Silivia JS 1, Anton Carla JS 1, Chiriță Oana JS 1, Focsa Lavinia JS1, Ivanciuc Sorin JS1, Matei Oana JS 1, Paduraru Dana JS 1, Savu Ana JS 1, Bogdan Popescu JUdecatoria Tg Jiu, Lucian Cosmin Manoloiu – Judecatoria Slatina, Irina Popa JS 1, Gheorghe Costin Lucian Judecătoria Cornetu, Dinu Rebeca Zinca Trib Bucuresti, Brindusa Andreea Sarbu JS 1, Veronica Sirbu JS4, Cristi Danilet – Tribunalul Cluj, Roxana Budulan – CA Timisoara, Bichis Diana Maria – Judecatoria Dej, Carpinean Cristiana Camelia – Judecatoria Dej, Tudor Cristian Ciobanu – Judecatoria Raducaneni, Oana Andreea Onofrei JS 1, Alina Mihaela Palancanu – Tribunalul Neamt, Marius Stancu JS1, Alexandra Ghica JS1, Ana Maria Stoica – JS1, Edwina Guiu – JS1, Andreea Balutoiu JS1, Cristina Călușaru – Tribunalul Dolj, Mandache Claudia – Judecatoria Iasi, Andreea Busulescu – JS1, Andreea Mihaela Bradu – Tribunalul București, Iulia Lavinia Munteanu – Judecătoria IAși
De asemenea, apreciem gestul de solidaritate al colegilor auditori de justitie care au dorit să se alăture demersului nostru: CIORNEI Dan Constantin, CREȚAN Alexandru, GRĂJDEANU Constantin, VARVARA Maria, TARNOVSCHI Alexandra-Karina, BRÎNAȘ Liviu Florin, CALAI Patricia Carmen, DERLEAN Petru Alexandru, SIMION Boris, JOLDOȘ Andrada Iulia, POP Paula Crina, SOPONOȘ Cristina, SZILAGHY Robert-Tiberiu, ALCOR Mona, COTOI Petruța Maria, FARCAȘ Carmen Mihaela, NEACȘU Mirel-Emanuel, PASCU Diana, MAIOR Sandra, IVĂNUȘ Camelia-Laura, VOROTIC Lavinia, BONDAR Elena Teodora, CRISTEA Emilia, CRISTEA Ștefan-Georgian, DĂNILĂ Sanda Cristina, FILIP Tudor-Petruț, POP Florina Maria, POPA Mihai, RĂCHITĂ Ioana Ruxandra, POPA Maria Denisa, TOMA Andreea, APOSTU Roxana, ARON Denisa, CIOCOIU Georgiana-Mihaela, GAVRIL Ducu, JERE Amalia, ȘINCARI Florin, BUCUR Ioana, BÂRSAN Dan Andrei, DOFIN Cătălin Liviu, HURDUCACIU Mădălin, URSUȚ Cristian, VERDE Andreea, BELCHIȚĂ Mihai Alexandru, MOROȘAN Maria-Magdalena, Lazăr Mihaela, Mădălina Elena Cazan, Pasea Irina, Ungureanu Alina Nicoleta, Teodoru Raluca, Ivan Lavinia Constantina, Gruia Streinu, Roxana Beatrice Teslovan, Oltean Sorana Zamfira, Caraus Nicolae, Jarca Cristian Paul, Stoicescu Andreea, Ostahie Oana Maria, Cîmpean Laura Monica, Doroftei Georgiana, Pintea Razvan Mihaita, Bratu Adriana Marinela, Pop Andrei, Chichinejdi Paul Sebastian, Lapadat Adina Stefania, Nicoara Alexandra Ioana, Sinziana Benec, Cercega Lidia Claudia, Varvara Maria Auditor, Guz Jean Robert, Tremură Mirel Cristian, Geambasu Daria Alexandra, Calai Patricia Carmen, Bacoiu Diana Mădălina, Voiculescu Corina Alexandra, Boteanu Teona Gabriela, Necula Mihai
The undersigned, prosecutors within the Public Ministry, observing the principle of the separation of powers in the state and the general requirement to abstain from having any particular political stance, taking note of the public discussions on the duties and activity of the prosecutors as well as the issues inserted in the minutes of the Romanian Constitutional Court’s decision dated May 30, 2018,
In view of the Bangalore Principles that allow magistrates to freely express their opinions when their independence is affected or when there is a risk of prejudicing the separation and balance of powers in the state,
Taking into account the standards imposed by the United Nations Principles on the role of the Prosecutor, adopted in Havana in 1990, the Council of Europe Recommendation (2000) 19 on the role of the prosecutor in the criminal justice system, Professional Accountability Standards and the Declaration on the Obligations and Rights of Public Prosecutors adopted by the International Association of Prosecutors on 23 April 1999, the Venice Commission’s Report on European Standards for the Independence of the Judiciary (CDL_AD (2010) 040) adopted on 17-18 December 2010, Opinion no. 9 (2014) of the Consultative Council of European Prosecutors (Rome Charter)
Considering that the Romanian State understands to fulfil its international obligations regarding the independence of the judiciary and the protection of the rule of law and to observe the rules imposed by the European Union and the Council of Europe as well as by the other international organizations of which Romania is part of,
we understand to commit at individual level to the declaration of principles below:
Our activity will always take place in accordance with the constitutional role provided by art. 131 par. (1) of the Romanian Constitution, defending the general interests of society, the rule of law as well as the rights and freedoms of citizens. We respect the competences of the Minister of Justice regarding the state’s criminal policy as well as the specific attributions in certain areas, but these competences do not validate in any way the involvement of the political factor in the ways of investigating and solving criminal cases. The Minister of Justice has no and will not have any involvement or role in our professional activity or in any criminal or civil case that we have for resolution or where we participate as representatives of the Public Ministry.
The only institution that manages the career of the prosecutor and the only guarantor of the independence of prosecutors is the Superior Council of Magistracy and according to art. 1 par. (2) of Law 304/2004the Minister of Justice has and can have no role or involvement in the individual career of the prosecutor, and this principle cannot be modified by inserting a specific phrase in the Constitutional Court’s decision, an institution which has no competence to legislate positively. We draw attention to the fact that the professional evaluation of prosecutors and the way in which they are to take office must be based on a meritocratic system, on clear and transparent conditions and rules and a lack of arbitrariness.
We urge all competent institutions and all decision-makers to respect the principles of the functioning of the European Union, to facilitate the fulfilment of Romania’s international obligations and take into account that respect for the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary is an important point in the field of international cooperation and the capacity of Romania to be a partner of dialogue in relation to the other Member States, both with regards to cooperation in criminal matters and cooperation in civil matters.
In support of this statement of principle we note that guaranteeing the independence of the judiciary was one of the conditions required for membership of the European Union, a context in which the changes to the package of laws on the judiciary were adopted, specifically guaranteeing the independence and stability of the prosecutor, by amending the provisions of art. 3 par. (1) of Law 303/2004 („The prosecutors appointed by the President of Romania enjoy stability and are independent, according to the law”). Romania’s obligation regarding the rule of law and guaranteeing the independence of the judiciary continued after the moment of accession, being one of the criteria considered in the CVM evaluations, so we cannot consider that an approach that diminishes the statute of the prosecutor magistrate could be anything other than an infringement of the commitments assumed as a Member State.
We also draw attention to the fact that the Havana Rules on the role of the Prosecutor, adopted by the United Nations in 1990, require States to ensure that prosecutors can exercise their functions without being exposed to intimidation, harassment and interference.
As a member of the Council of Europe, the Romanian state must consider and respect international notices, and in this respect the Charter of Rome lays down as European standards and principles regarding the activity of prosecutors the following: „Independence and autonomy of the Public Ministry is a indispensable corollary to the independence of the judiciary. Prosecutors should be autonomous in decision-making and should carry out their tasks outside any external interference and pressure, according to the principles of separation of powers and responsibility „
The independence of the prosecutor and the prosecutor’s impartiality are two essential elements in international standards, being regarded as key human rights issues, both from an institutional as well as an individual point of view. The independence and impartiality of the prosecutor magistrate are not his personal benefits but the guarantees necessary for the fulfilment of the function of the Public Ministry in the structure of a law-based state or the authority responsible for the enforcement of the criminal law on behalf of and for the benefit of society and the public interest, taking into account both the rights of the individual and the necessary effectiveness of the criminal justice system. (Council of Europe Recommendation (2000) 19, paragraph 1)
Both the Council of Europe Recommendation and the Venice Commission Report underline the need to ensure transparent and fair procedures with no political influence in terms of admission to the profession, promotion system and prosecutor’s work. Thus, the procedures guaranteeing a correct selection of prosecutors and those protecting the prosecutor from an arbitrary removal are important issues in guaranteeing the independence of the prosecutor. There is no benefit in creating a system in which the prosecutor is only apparently independent if the practical actions tend to involve the political factor in the judicial activity.
In this respect, the Venice Commission underlined that the prosecutor’s independence is a mechanism to prevent the interference of the political or any other factor in the criminal prosecution activity and states must provide the necessary framework for the prosecutor’s decisions to be taken impartially and just as the judge is required to act fairly and impartially without being subjected to the pressure of other external factors.
The Venice Commission report on judicial independence emphasizes that „A clear distinction needs to be made between the interest of persons holding power in the State and the general interest. The assumption that the two aspects overlap is present in many European countries. Ideally, the exercise of functions of general interest must not be combined or confused with the functions of the executive power at a particular moment in time, the interests of other institutions, or even the interests of any political party.” Considering the legal obligations of the Public Ministry, both at constitutional level and at the level of other legal instruments, we underline that as prosecutors our role is to defend the public interest, understood as the interest of the citizens in a democratic state and we will exercise this role independently and impartially, without regard to temporary circumstance.
List of signatures:
- Bradea Dumitru Vlad – Parchetul de pe lângă Judecătoria Oradea
- Corina Dinică – PT Argeș
- Lăncrănjan Alexandra Carmen – DNA Structura Centrală
- Margina Cătălin – PT Bacău
- Tagheiv Ramona – PT Bacău
- Finică Sorina – PT Bacău
- Atomei Adriana – PT Bacău
- Trif Marian Mihai – PJ Turda
- Iulia Crișan – DNA Structura Centrală
- Simona Anghel – PJ Oltenita
- Mihaela Beldie – DNA Structura Centrală
- Răzvan Alexandru Băra – PJ Brașov
- Cristina Scarlat DNA
- Aurelian Ioan Ardelean – DNA
- Radu Florin Ionescu – DNA
- Cosmin Iordache – DNA
- Adriana Pau – PJ Sector 2
- Codreanu Alexandru – PT Brașov
- Raluca Alexandra Munteanu – PJ Sector 2
- Berende Ruxandra Maria PJ Satu Mare
- Roxana Andreea Codreanu PJ IAsi
- Laurentiu Grecu – PT Gorj
- Lia Sorin Marian – PJ Corabia
- Carmen VAmesu – DNA
- Daniela Lupu – DNA
- Alexandru Liviu Colceriu – PJ Intorsura Buzaului
- Cosmina Mihaela Vieriu – PJ Zarnesti
- Calin Radu Bogdan – PJ Sector 1
- Coralia Lapadat – PJ Arad
- Dordea Marcian Silviu – PJ Blaj
- Luminita Boca – DNA ST Cluj
- Bogdan Pîrlog – PT Militar Bucuresti
- Andra Dutescu – PJ Sector 2
- Stroescu Bobby Sorin – PJ Timisoara
- Curici Seia Iasmina- PJ Deta
- Ghita Alina Andreea – PJ Turda
- Laura Dobrea – PT Brăila
- Ciutac Mircea – PT Brăila
- Dedulescu Liviu Ionuț – PT Brăila
- Velea Gheorghe – PJ Brăila
- Marinescu Mihaela – PJ Însurăței
- Pungă Tudorel – PJ Însurăței
- Baraș Iulian – PJ Bolintin Vale
- Barbu Camelia Liliana – PJ Bolintin Vale
- Tomescu Alexandra Sorina – PJ Bolintin Vale
- Cotovelea Ionel – PJ Câmpulung
- Gheorghe Daniel – PJ Câmpulung
- Lobodan Remus – PJ Câmpulung
- Visovan Cristina Ingrid – PJ Sighetu Marmatiei
- Adrian Meda Titu- DNA ST Cluj
- Irimia Anca Emilia – PJ Sibiu
- Cristina Frîncu – PJS 2
- Ioana Vernea PJS2
- Sohorca Florin PJ Alba Iulia
- Rotundu Simon PJ Iasi
- Cîrciumaru Oprică Florin PJS 2
- Doina Stanta – PCA Craiova
- Bunduc Marian Catalin – DIICOT Structura Centrală
- Arpinte Nicoleta – PJ Dorohoi
- Stanciu Gabriela – DNA ST Constanta
- Valentin Toduta – PJ oradea
- Bursuc Andreea Claudia – DIICOT
- Anca Iovan DIICOT Serviciul Teritorial Brasov
- Lohan Iulia Maria – PJ Sighetul Marmatiei
- Cristina Radu – PT Bucuresti
- Sendroni Mircea – PJ Cluj Napoca
- Marian Clement Virgil – PJ Baia Mare
- Asmarandei Andrei Iulian – PT Ilfov
- Carnariu Bianca Dana – PJ Baia Mare
- Gabriel Tatar – PJ Cluj Napoca
- Tabirta Lorin PJ Timisoara
- Carnariu Mihai Madalin – PJ Baia Mare
- Buzoianu Mihaela Alexandra – PJ Calarasi
- Valentin Uritescu – PJ Negresti Oas
- Cosmin Ungureanu PT Valcea
- Vlad Alexandru Bentan – PJ oradea
- Marin Ana Maria PT Brasov
- Ioana Gutu PT Valcea
- Daniel Giorgian PJ galati
- Cristina Voicu DNA Structura Centrala
- Morosan Andrada Sabina PJ Timisoara
- Pop Blaga Marius PJ Oradea
- Alba Radu Ioan PJ Oradea
- Popescu Adriana Mihaela PT Valcea
- Radu Adrian PJ Brasov
- Ostafie Andrei PJ Botosani
- Laura Zaharia DIICOT Iasi
- Ciobanu Ionica Daniel PJ Caracal
- Mihaela Mihai Popa – DNA ST Suceava
- Marin Călusaru – DNA ST Craiova
- Ramona Jardieanu – DNA Structura Centrala
- Damaschin Ioana Teodora – PJ Cluj Napoca
- Bocai Adina PCA Iasi
- Mihai Negulescu DIICOT ST Brasov
- Dobre Aurelia Madalina PJ Arad
- Panainte Iulian PJ Harlau
- Sorin Daniel Beteringhe PT Bihor
- Paunica Ionut PJ Calarasi
- Gus Octavia Raluca PT Alba
- Pacuraru Mihaela PJ Calarasi
- Marinescu Lucian PT Valcea
- Burga Florin PJ Sf Gheorghe
- Matei Leontin PJS 4
- Pitrop Cristina Beatrice PJ Constanta
- Ioan Bene PJ TG Bujor
- Sandu Claudiu Costantin PT Brasov
- Mihail Andreca PJ Timisoara
- Mihai Valentin DIICOT Structura Centrală
- Dobre Mihai Alexandru PJ Arad
- Onea Dalidis Nicoleta Irina PCA Craiova
- Iulian Nica – PT Brasov
- Anghel Alexandru Bogdan PJ Segarcea
- Serban Viorel Florin PJS 2
- Iulia Bilciu DNA Structura Centrala
- Daniel Ciumărnean DNA ST Cluj
- Paul Dumitriu DNA Structura Centrală
- Danusia Boicean DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Alina RAsovan DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Daniel Dumitru DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Călin Tatu DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Florin Nanu DNA ST Alba Iulia
- Anca Gabriela Mărincean DNA ST Cluj
- Horatius Baias DNA Structura Centrală
- Stancele Diana DNA Structura Centrala
- Constantin Irina DNA Structura Centrala
- Daniel Apetroaei – DNA St Bacău
- Anemaria Ruxandra Cireap – DNA
- Oana Peltechi – PCA Bucuresti
- Roca Carmil DNA ST Bacău
- Robert Adrian Nicolicescu DNA
- Daniela Dumitrache – DNA
- Violeta Sechely – DNA Structura Centrală
- Florin Bogdan Munteanu DNA ST Iasi
- Iordache Laura Nicoleta PJS 1
- Lucanu Iuliana DIICOT
- Tudor Antoniu Vasiu – PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Adi Lucian Răduică PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Pena Laura Nadia PCA Bacau
- Gheorghe Mihai Andrei PJ Pitesti
- Puscas Madalina PJ Alba Iulia
- Zlate Nadia DNA ST Constanta
- David Maricel – PT Ilfov
- Povăliceanu Cristina – PT Arad
- Roman Nelu – PJ Baia Mare
- Bradin Aurora PJ Arad
- Monica Munteanu DNA ST Brasov
- Vestemeanu Raluca DIICOT ST Brasov
- Cornel David Deca DNA ST Brasov
- Andreea Ghenu DNA ST Brasov
- Dundev Alma Maria PJ Sighisoara
- Batrinu Iuliana PJ Focsani
- Brindea Dan Eugen PT Salaj
- Cepoi Marian PJ Nasaud
- Dunca Ioan PJ Baia Mare
- Varga Zoltan PJ Baia Mare
- Scutea Gabriela PCA Brasov
- Ghita Bogdan – DNA
- Bontea Cristina Augustina PJ Petrosani
- Baldea Diana PT IAsi
- Satmarici Iulia Diana PJ Medgidia
- Mircea Alexandra Nora PJ Turda
- Radu Florea PJ Turda
- Ghidiu Liliana Maria PT Alba
- Panciuc Anca Clara – PJ Radauti
- Remus Budai – DNA Structura Centrala
- Ion Izabela Ana Maria PJ Sector 3
- Stefanita Gogea DIICOT
- Cristina Chiriac DNA
- Cosarca Nicolae PJ Targu Mures
- Diremia Vlad PJ Rosiori De vede
- Buda Dorel PJ Baia Mare
- Alice Jemboiu PCA Craiova
- Maria Piturcă PCA Craiova
- Marius Sulu PT Brasov
- Grigore alina Gabriela PJ Targoviste
- Mihai Irina PJ Targoviste
- Bosânciuc Paul Cosmin PJ Targoviste
- Stoica Florin PJ Targoviste
- Aldea Adrian PT Brasov
- Cerasela Ungureanu PT Brasov
- Câțu Lilisor PJ Brasov
- Câțu Codruța Romana Maria PJ Brasov
- Nita Manole Simona Daniela PJ Ploiesti
- Dragu Corina PT Brasov
- Fânariu Stefan PJ Saveni
- Nistor Gigi PJ Filiasi
- Cristina Mocioi PJ Babadag
- Ursa Paul Ionel PJ Zarnesti
- Comanescu Cătălin PJ Horezu
- Ana Muresan PJS 2 delegat PTB
- Nită Manole Simona Daniela PJ Ploiesti
- Corina Avornicitei PJ Sector 1
- Raluca Anghel Gheorghe DNA Structura Centrală
- Alin Eduard Poterasu DNA Structura Centrala
- Veronica Luminita Leonte DNA ST Suceava
- Maria Luiza Capatana DNA Structura Centrală
- Mosteanu Marian Eugen DNA ST Craiova
- Ionuț Vasile DNA ST Cluj
- Alexandru Diana DNA ST Galați
- Popescu Gabriela DNA ST Galați
- Ivascu Dorina DNA ST Galați
- Mihaela Leu DNA ST Galați
- Năvădaru Mădălin DNA ST Galați
- Lucian Rău DNA ST Galați
- Diana Alexandru DNA ST Galați
- Andreea Oana Nica DNA
- Eugen Stănculescu DNA ST Craiova
- Tiberiu Nicolae Onea – DNA ST Tîrgu Mureș
- Drăgulescu Marian DNA Structura Centrală
- Gabriela Iancu DNA ST Cluj
- Ioana Borjog PJ Sector 1
- Ionela Bălan DNA Structura Centrală
- Ana Maria Nedelcu DNA Structura Centrală
- Cornelia Hrincescu DNA ST Bacău
- Antonia Diaconu – PJ Topoloveni
- Nanu Vladimir PT Argeș
- Moraru Alina – DNA ST Iasi
- Dorcu Lavinia PJ Corabia
- Irina Paraschiv PJ Brezoi
- Stefan Ispasoiu DNA ST Brasov
- Gheorghiu Anca Loredana PJ Brasov
- Corina Mois PJ Satu Mare
- Miu Madalina PT Calarasi
- Marinel Nicolae PT Olt
- Couti Roxana PT Maramures
- Maris Constantina PT Maramures
- Apetri Oana PT Brasov
- Couti Crinel PT Maramures
- Simion Oana PJ Brasov
- Rosca Sergiu PJ Satu Mare
- Claudiu Statache PJ Constanta
- Stasiuc Mădălina PJ Targu Mures
- Alexandra Dordea DNA Structura Centrală
- Branzei Alexandru PJ Baia Mare
- Baran Florin PJ Sector 4
- Rus Lavinia PJ Faget
- Mircea Iuliana PCA Constanta
- Ioan Sandru PICCJ
- Dan Obreja PJ TG Mures
- Maria Rimniceanu DIICOT ST BRASOV
- Azamfirei Daniela Elena PJ Galati
- Cristina Maria Luca PT Neamț
- Pelmuș Ciprian PJ Timisoara
- Arvinte Ramona PJS3
- Olteanu Dragoș PJ Timisoara
- Catalin Moraru PJ Brasov
- Vlad Crăciun PJ Sighisoara
- Pelinel Monica Cristina PT Valcea
- Ghinea Alexandru Cosmin PJ Fetesti
- Sorin Constantinescu DNA ST Constanta
- Apostol Mihaela PT Iasi
- Cojoaca Traian PJ Rosiori de Vede
- Munge Mircea Florin PJ Oradea
- Alina Hubert PJ Pitesti
- Topliceanu Constantin PJ Pitesti
- Doncea Andrei PT Ilfov
- Ungureanu Alin PJ Deta
- Ceaușu Alexandru Octavian PJ Timisoara
- Blanaru Larisa Andreea PJ Brasov
- Mocanu Simona Elena PJ Brasov
- Aurelian Manzu PT Arad
- Alina Ghinescu DIICOT ST CV
- Bochis Angela PJ Cornetu
- Dumitrache Nicusor Adrian PJS 4
- Olca Diana Andreea PJ Satu Mare
- Sovarschi Laura PJ Alesd
- Lazar Ancuta PJ Satu Mare
- Meszaros Ioana Adina PJ Satu mare
- Betea Florin Dorin PJ Satu Mare
- Mic Ioana PT satu Mare
- Bocai Tudor Florin PT Hunedoara
- Cuciureanu Iulia Maria PJ Brasov
- Iordache Valeriu PJ Ploiesti
- Airinei Lucia PT Harghita
- Iosifescu Iulian Răzvan PT Harghita
- Colceriu Sorin Mihai PT Harghita
- Gîlcescu Dan PT Harghita
- Grigore Cristian PT Harghita
- Fabian Orsolya Kinga PT Harghita
- Tokos Lehel PT Harghita
- Deac Corvin Doru PJ Miercurea Ciuc
- German Cristina PJ Miercurea Ciuc
- Chiriac Dragos PJ Miercurea Ciuc
- Ivănescu Georgică PJ Odorheiu Secuiesc
- Suto Agota Kinga PJ Odorheiu Secuiesc
- Papuc Mădălina Diana PJ Odorheiu Secuiesc
- Vasile Tudor Iulian PJ Fetesti
- Buculea Raluca PJ Timisoara
- Popa Alina Diana PJ Iasi
- Marcu Ionut DIICOT
- Cristina Gavriliuc DNA ST Bacau
- Giluela Deaconu DNA
- Ioan Ulici DNA
- Cerasela Răileanu DNA
- Angelica Paraschivescu DNA ST Pitesti
- Dana Păun PJS1
- Florina Nicoleta Sirbu PJS1
- Maria Mihut PJS 2
- Corina Petrescu PJS 1
- Florea Alexandru DIICOT
- Preda Andrei Bogdan DIICOT
- Dan Cristian Ene DIICOT
- Cristian Florea DIICOT
- Ionela Florea DIICOT
- Apostol Giorgiana Violeta PJ Constanta
- Nita Cosmin PJ Ploiesti
- Ciotu Roxana PJ Suceava
- Pirvu Ana Maria PJ Slobozia
- Totora Vlad Cosmin PJ Segarcea
- Cioban Vasile Călin PJ Turda
- Valentin Enache PJ Brezoi
- Simona Stefania Constantinescu DNA
- Iuliana Mihoc PJ Ploiesti
- Neculaica Elena PT Constanta
- Oprea Veronica Nicoleta PJ Buzău delegat DNA ST Ploiesti
- Salaru Ilie Andrei PJS1
- Colț Mihail PJ Brăila
- Ionela Tinca PJ Brașov
- Buse Ionel PJ Valcea
- Tosu Zoltan Eugen PJ Dragasani
- Florentina Mirica DNA Structura Centrală
- Streza Laurentiu PJ Valcea
- Sava Alexandra Teona PJ Harlau
- Serban irina PJ Slatina
- Stefan Gheorghe Daniel PT Bacau
- Bogdan Stoica PJ Dragasani
- Marius Valcu DNA Structura Centrală
- Lazar Anca PCA Cluj
- Popescu Cristian Ovidiu PJ Caracal
- Gheorghe Popovici DNA Structura Centrală
- Ungureanu Irina PJ Sighisoara
- Ursu Oana Alina PJ Giurgiu
- Rosiu Mihaela PJS 5
- Zavera Irina PJ Timisoara
- Sas Anca Raluca PJ Turda
- Lungu Ramona PT Arad
- Lazăr Aida PJ Timisoara
- Rusu Larisa PJ Botosani
- Raluca Nor Bosnea PJ Timisoara
- Cîmpean Ioana Elena PJS 2
- Povaliceanu Claudia PJ Timisoara
- Bradean Raluca Cristina PJ Caransebes
- Ailioaei Ramona PJ Pascani
- Stoenescu Roxana PJS 4
- Cătălin Galcea PJS4
- Hogas Marius PJ Râmnicu Vâlcea
- Stroe Cristina PJ Dragasani
- Mociran Adela PT Maramures
- Tătar Emanuela Anca PJ Brăila
- Sfîca Aglaia Irina PJ Iasi
- Fraiu Flaviu PJ Timișoara
- Galatan Anișoara Voichita PJS 6
- Simon Dragos PJ Cluj Napoca
- Todea LAurentiu Mirel PJ Timisoara
- Derius Laura DNA Structura Centrala
- Pop Ciprian Dumitru PJ Ludus
- Murariu Ovidiu Daniel PJ Ludus
- Ciuche Lucian DIICOT
- Dinică Mihai PJ Făurei
- Topală Teodor Bogdan DIICOT
- Meszar Alexandru Voicu PJ Carei
- Pricop Elena Mădălina PJ Iași
- Țapliuc Cristina PJ Iasi
- Corogeanu Cristian Andrei PJ Timisoara
- Albulescu Camelia PJ Cornetu
- Ioșca Alina PJ Cornetu
- Serban Daniel Mihai PJ Brașov
- Gordan Sorin PT Brăila
- Chivu Claudia Irina PJ Timisoara
- Olariu Nicusor PJ Caransebes
- Mustață Liviu PT Caraș Severin
- Hosu Andrei PT Caraș Severin
- Patras Alexandra Maria PJ Iași
- Pelmus Atena PT Timiș
- Mihoc Emanuel PJ Sighișoara
- Galatanu Maria PJ Baia Mare
- Simion Daniel PJ Focsani
- Stanciu Gabriela Daniela PJ Brăila
- Corogeanu Cristian Andrei PJ Timișoara
- Negrău Andrei Sergiu PJ Salonta
- Georgescu Ruxandra Diana PJ Suceava
- Călinescu Diana PJ Suceava
- Cătălin Chiochiu PJ Suceava
- Doina Popa PJ Pitești
- Nicolae Argeșanu PJ Pitești
- Simona Florescu PJ Pitești
- Cătălin Barbuceanu PCA Pitești
- Oprea Mihai Tatiana DIICOT
- Olaru Mihaiela DIICOT
- Cristian Ichim DIICOT ST Brasov
- Zaharia Adrian Constantin PJ Suceava
- Cristina Garda PJ Galați
- Scorta Robert PJ Petrosani
- Popescu Cristian PJ Caracal
- Bonda Alexandru Vasile PJ Timisoara
- Andrei Florin Ciprian DIICOT Bacău
- Ciocan Gheorghe PJ Severin
- Marin Călușaru DNA ST Craiova
- Varga Sanda Daria PCA Cluj
- Diana Nicoleta Gitan PT Timiș
- Constantin Conortos DNA ST Constanta
- Diac Ana Maria PJS1
- Crăciun Achim Ovidiu PJ Brăila
- Luminița Popa DNA
- Emanuel Hau PJ Timișoara
- Daniela Chiazna PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Florina Băilescu PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Bărbulescu Florin Alexandru PJ Călărași
- Natavala Iuliu DNA
- Vlad Grigorescu DNA
- Tiba Morar Anca PJ Oradea
- Ion Teodor Valentin PJ Pitești
- Adrian Mihai PJ Pitești
- Cosmin Cristescu PJ Pitești
- Puiulescu Constantin Cosmin PT Argeș
- Ioan Paul Chiș DNA Structura Centrală
- Paul Leontică DIICOT ST Suceava
- Florentin Riza PT Dolj
- Tamara Manea PICCJ
- Adrian Ghirdoveanu DIICOT BT Dambovita
- Resmeriță Clement Mihai – DNA Structura Centrală
- Conortos Camelia Maria PT Constanta
- Constantinescu Mihai Marius DIICOT
- Ardelean Cristian DNA ST Oradea
- Chiazna Magdalena Daniela PJ Drobeta Turnu Severin
- Moacă Mihaela Adriana PJ Buftea
- Ionuț Călina DIICOT
- Ionascu Cristina PJ Bacău
- Ionascu Cătălin PJ Bacău
- Benchea Vlad PJ Sibiu
- Mandache Ionut PJ Iași
- Fleckhammer Robert DIICOT
- Petrescu Erită Cosmin PJ Tg Jiu
- Onofrei Nichiforel Marius PT Botoșani
- Cristea Virgil – PJ Alba Iulia
- Cristea Denisa PJ Constanta
- Șimon Oana PJ Cluj Napoca
- Horșia Alexandru PJ Cluj Napoca
- Panțiru Florin PJ Cluj Napoca
- Spumă Oana Amalia PJ Cluj Napoca
- Mărginean Peczi Anamaria PJ Cluj Napoca
- Fadei Pavel PJ Cluj Napoca
- Nicoară Andra Laura PJ Cluj Napoca
- Ududec Ionel PJ Cluj Napoca
- Pantea Marius Călin PJ Cluj Napoca
- Tofan Florinela PJ Cluj Napoca
- Horge Diana Maria PJ Cluj Napoca
- Gheorghe Dragoș Ion PJ Cluj Napoca
- Mihai Laura Adina PJ Cluj Napoca
- Amuscăliței Alin PJ Cluj Napoca
- Mane Loredana Lăcrămioara PJ Cluj Napoca
- Birtoc Mihai Dorin PJ Cluj Napoca
- Delea Sarca Georgiana PJ Cluj Napoca
- Toader Aurelia Mirel PJ Cluj Napoca
- Ududec Anca Teodora PJ Cluj Napoca
- Kozma Bartok Szende Zenko PJ Cluj Napoca
- Borteș Mihai PJ Cluj Napoca
- Damaschin Ioana Teodora PJ Cluj Napoca
- Andreica Lucia Maria PJ Cluj Napoca
- Sfâriac Mihaela PT Cluj
- Renyi Erika PT Cluj
- Rășcanu Cristina PT Cluj
- Mihai Mesaros PJS 2
- Dinu Adrian Mihai PJ Constanta
- Laurentiu Iordan PJ Sibiu
- Cazacu Dan Constantin PJ Bacău
- Felicia Irina Popovici DNA
- Felicia Vlad DNA ST Brasov
- Adina Bidică PT Valcea
- Alexandra Maria Zernoveanu PJ Sfantu Gheorghe
- Cășuneanu Florin Daniel – PCA Iași
- Cojocar Rusanda PJ Brasov
- Gherghina Alina Nicoleta PJS 6
- Paduraru Raluca Mihaela PJS4
- Dinu Cristian Sorin DIICOT BT Sibiu
- Enache Simona DIICOT BT Sibiu
- Sava Gheorghe Petru DIICOT BT Sibiu
- Bidihon Flavius PJ Suceava
- Meszaros Tiberiu PJ Babadag
- Miroiu Floriana PJS 4
- Laura Gradina PT Tulcea
- Cristina Grosaru PJS 3
- Stefaniu Simona PT Covasna
- Stefaniu Bogdan PT Covasna
- Alina Neculaes PCA Bacău
- Andrei Jurca PJ Timisoara
- Sorin Pasăre PCA Craiova
- Pătulea Ioana – PJS 3
- Rosu Cristina PJ Giurgiu
- Mihaela Grigore PCA Bacau
- Andrei Dragan PJ Buftea
- Andrei Cristi PJ Răcari
- Carasel Stefana PJS 1
- Petrusca Gabriela Amalia PJ Buftea
- Ghilan Irina Brîndușa PJ Moinești
- Sandu Anca – PJ Piatra Neamț
- Ciopi Ani – PJ Baia Mare
- Matei Andreea Isabella PJ Buhusi
- Sarghi Dorina PJ Roman
- Maciuc Sorin PJS 6
Mulțumim colegilor judecători care susțin acest demers: Florin Zeres – Judecatoria Sibiu, Florina Carmen Ionescu – Tribunalul Neamt, Doina Zavalasi- CA Craiova, Mihaela Ion – Judecătoria Buzău, Iulian Dîrzeanu – Tribunalul București, Sorina Marinaș -CA Craiova, Florin Vilceanu – Tribunal Bucuresti, Ioana Liliana Molina Ramirez – Tribunalul Cluj, Anca Codreanu – Tribunalul Brașov, Liviu Cristian Cirneciu – Judecătoria Zărnesti, Cirneciu Felicia Tincuta – JS 2, Anca Demian – Judecatoria Hateg, Padeanu Catalina Petruta – Judecatoria Slatina, Sandu Maria Irina – Judecatoria Brasov, Madalina Birlog – Tribunalul Bucuresti, Cobiscan Alexandru – JS 1, Ioan Fundatureanu – CA Pitesti, Crina Capota – Judecatoria Dej, Balasanu Alexandru – Judecatoria Botosani, Popescu Adrian – Tribunalul Cluj, Popescu Luminita Teodora Judecatoria Mangalia, Neagos Sorina – CA Alba Iulia, Mandache Claudia – Judecătoria Iași, Dorin Parascheva – Judecatoria Constanta, Alina Stamate Tamasan – Tribunalul Maramures, Ambrozie Silivia JS 1, Anton Carla JS 1, Chiriță Oana JS 1, Focsa Lavinia JS1, Ivanciuc Sorin JS1, Matei Oana JS 1, Paduraru Dana JS 1, Savu Ana JS 1, Bogdan Popescu JUdecatoria Tg Jiu, Lucian Cosmin Manoloiu – Judecatoria Slatina, Irina Popa JS 1, Gheorghe Costin Lucian Judecătoria Cornetu, Dinu Rebeca Zinca Trib Bucuresti, Brindusa Andreea Sarbu JS 1, Veronica Sirbu JS4, Cristi Danilet – Tribunalul Cluj, Roxana Budulan – CA Timisoara, Bichis Diana Maria – Judecatoria Dej, Carpinean Cristiana Camelia – Judecatoria Dej, Tudor Cristian Ciobanu – Judecatoria Raducaneni, Oana Andreea Onofrei JS 1, Alina Mihaela Palancanu – Tribunalul Neamt, Marius Stancu JS1, Alexandra Ghica JS1, Ana Maria Stoica – JS1, Edwina Guiu – JS1, Andreea Balutoiu JS1, Cristina Călușaru – Tribunalul Dolj, Mandache Claudia – Judecatoria Iasi, Andreea Busulescu – JS1, Andreea Mihaela Bradu – Tribunalul București, Iulia Lavinia Munteanu – Judecătoria IAși
De asemenea, apreciem gestul de solidaritate al colegilor auditori de justitie care au dorit să se alăture demersului nostru: CIORNEI Dan Constantin, CREȚAN Alexandru, GRĂJDEANU Constantin, VARVARA Maria, TARNOVSCHI Alexandra-Karina, BRÎNAȘ Liviu Florin, CALAI Patricia Carmen, DERLEAN Petru Alexandru, SIMION Boris, JOLDOȘ Andrada Iulia, POP Paula Crina, SOPONOȘ Cristina, SZILAGHY Robert-Tiberiu, ALCOR Mona, COTOI Petruța Maria, FARCAȘ Carmen Mihaela, NEACȘU Mirel-Emanuel, PASCU Diana, MAIOR Sandra, IVĂNUȘ Camelia-Laura, VOROTIC Lavinia, BONDAR Elena Teodora, CRISTEA Emilia, CRISTEA Ștefan-Georgian, DĂNILĂ Sanda Cristina, FILIP Tudor-Petruț, POP Florina Maria, POPA Mihai, RĂCHITĂ Ioana Ruxandra, POPA Maria Denisa, TOMA Andreea, APOSTU Roxana, ARON Denisa, CIOCOIU Georgiana-Mihaela, GAVRIL Ducu, JERE Amalia, ȘINCARI Florin, BUCUR Ioana, BÂRSAN Dan Andrei, DOFIN Cătălin Liviu, HURDUCACIU Mădălin, URSUȚ Cristian, VERDE Andreea, BELCHIȚĂ Mihai Alexandru, MOROȘAN Maria-Magdalena, Lazăr Mihaela, Mădălina Elena Cazan, Pasea Irina, Ungureanu Alina Nicoleta, Teodoru Raluca, Ivan Lavinia Constantina, Gruia Streinu, Roxana Beatrice Teslovan, Oltean Sorana Zamfira, Caraus Nicolae, Jarca Cristian Paul, Stoicescu Andreea, Ostahie Oana Maria, Cîmpean Laura Monica, Doroftei Georgiana, Pintea Razvan Mihaita, Bratu Adriana Marinela, Pop Andrei, Chichinejdi Paul Sebastian, Lapadat Adina Stefania, Nicoara Alexandra Ioana, Sinziana Benec, Cercega Lidia Claudia, Varvara Maria Auditor, Guz Jean Robert, Tremură Mirel Cristian, Geambasu Daria Alexandra, Calai Patricia Carmen, Bacoiu Diana Mădălina, Voiculescu Corina Alexandra, Boteanu Teona Gabriela, Necula Mihai
No related posts.